下载2016年度阅卷评委对参赛报告之评语-Reviewers.PDF

Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants QP Case Analysis Competition 2016 (PRC) Reviewers Comments Comments on the Written Reports CONTENT Strengths Weaknesses  Clear problem identification, clear  Need to analyze more about corporate discussion and decision focus. governance, tax structure and  Well-organized composition, most of the government policy. necessary components are included and  SWOT analysis for the three strategies have been put in the right places. are not based on objective and accurate  In-depth analysis on the present situation environment. and proposals.  Conclusion for choosing strategy is  Supported with research findings and lacking of a sound theoretical and data. practical justification.  Identify problems clearly and articulation  It is not practical for suggesting a of solutions. solution but without considering the  The analysis of strategy choice has company current financial situation. strong logic and sufficient  The solution proposed is not matching to reasonableness, which makes the the company high quality product and conclusions of the investigation have a brand name mission and strategy. high degree of feasibility and  Has not showed enough consideration persuas